{ "note": "Second pass of the trend list, October 2026. Three AI models worked first separately and then with sight of each other; a fourth made the final cut to GINC's brief. The scenario side of the same pass is recorded at https://scenarios.ginc.org/data/second-pass.json.", "panel": [ { "key": "A", "model": "DeepSeek V4 Pro" }, { "key": "B", "model": "Mistral Large" }, { "key": "C", "model": "GPT-6.1" } ], "final_cut": "Claude", "trends": { "changes": { "note": "How the GINC 250 changed between the first pass and the second. A first-pass trend is carried forward where a final trend is the same force, merged where it was folded into a final trend that also continues another, and dropped where nothing in the final list continues it.", "counts": { "unchanged": 119, "renamed": 106, "moved_domain": 3, "merged": 15, "dropped": 9, "added": 24, "added_wholly_new": 24 }, "by_domain": [ { "domain": "critical-technology", "before": 26, "after": 28 }, { "domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "before": 34, "after": 29 }, { "domain": "national-security", "before": 28, "after": 28 }, { "domain": "human-capital", "before": 32, "after": 28 }, { "domain": "information-influence", "before": 25, "after": 27 }, { "domain": "governance-integrity", "before": 26, "after": 27 }, { "domain": "financial-strength", "before": 26, "after": 27 }, { "domain": "production-innovation", "before": 27, "after": 28 }, { "domain": "trade-investment", "before": 26, "after": 28 } ], "unchanged": [ "adaptive-regulation", "advanced-materials", "advanced-semiconductors", "africa-s-demographic-and-economic-rise", "agricultural-technology", "ai-accelerated-science", "ai-chips-and-accelerator-supply", "ai-drug-development", "ai-safety-and-governance", "alliance-realignment-and-burden-shifting", "alternative-proteins", "antimicrobial-resistance", "arctic-and-polar-competition", "arms-control-erosion", "asylum-and-migration-system-strain", "automated-ai-research", "autonomous-vehicles", "batteries-and-energy-storage", "biosecurity-and-dual-use-biology", "business-dynamism-and-start-up-formation", "capital-concentration-in-ai", "carbon-border-adjustments", "carbon-capture-utilisation-and-storage", "carbon-pricing-and-environmental-taxes", "censorship-and-surveillance", "central-bank-independence-under-pressure", "circular-materials-and-recycling", "citizen-participation-and-deliberative-democracy", "civil-service-capability-and-pay", "climate-change-and-physical-risk", "cloud-and-edge-computing", "compute-scaling-and-ai-infrastructure", "conscription-and-reserve-mobilisation", "conspiracy-movements-and-science-denial", "construction-productivity-and-housing-supply", "dams-reservoirs-and-flood-defence", "data-protection-and-digital-rights", "decline-of-independent-journalism", "declining-institutional-trust", "defence-industrial-base-and-munitions", "development-finance-as-influence", "diet-and-nutrition-shifts", "digital-public-infrastructure", "digital-sovereignty-and-data-localisation", "diplomatic-capacity-under-strain", "disaster-risk-finance", "distributed-power", "drone-and-autonomous-warfare", "drones-and-advanced-air-mobility", "economic-security-policy", "election-integrity-and-interference", "energy-import-dependence", "enhanced-geothermal", "erosion-of-rights-and-civic-freedoms", "espionage-and-insider-threat", "executive-overreach-and-emergency-powers", "financial-inclusion", "fiscal-rules-and-budget-credibility", "foreign-information-manipulation", "frontier-model-concentration", "fusion-energy", "gene-editing-and-cell-therapies", "global-health-governance", "global-south-coalitions", "great-power-competition", "household-debt-and-housing-affordability", "hydrogen-and-low-carbon-fuels", "illicit-finance-and-beneficial-ownership", "industrial-policy-competition", "insurance-retreat-and-insurability", "international-student-flows", "lithography-and-chip-tool-chokepoints", "local-and-city-government-capacity", "manufacturing-overcapacity", "medical-devices-and-neurotechnology", "militarisation-of-space", "misinformation-and-disinformation", "next-generation-mobile-networks", "non-bank-finance-growth", "ocean-economy", "official-statistics-and-data-capacity", "online-harms-and-safety", "open-source-intelligence-and-transparency", "open-weight-ai-diffusion", "organised-crime-and-illicit-economies", "outsourcing-and-public-private-delivery", "platform-power-over-public-discourse", "polarisation-and-populism", "post-quantum-cryptography-transition", "private-military-and-proxy-forces", "public-communication-in-crisis", "public-sector-ai-adoption", "quantum-computing", "rare-earth-processing-concentration", "rearmament-and-defence-spending", "regional-medicines-manufacturing", "regulatory-capture-and-lobbying-power", "religious-and-identity-nationalism", "remittance-dependence", "research-and-development-intensity", "research-security-and-science-decoupling", "reshoring-and-localised-manufacturing", "retail-and-food-service-automation", "rule-of-law-and-judicial-independence", "smart-manufacturing-and-digital-twins", "soft-power-and-cultural-influence", "sovereign-wealth-and-state-capital", "stablecoins-and-digital-currencies", "state-capacity-and-delivery", "state-fragility-and-intrastate-violence", "strategic-stockpiles-and-reserves", "synthetic-biology-and-biomanufacturing", "synthetic-media-and-deepfakes", "technical-standards-competition", "telecom-network-resilience", "terrorism-and-violent-extremism", "trade-finance-and-correspondent-banking-gaps", "weakening-multilateral-institutions", "whole-of-society-resilience" ], "renamed": [ { "from": "Access over ownership", "to": "Access over ownership models", "id": "access-over-ownership-models", "moved": null }, { "from": "Modern vaccines", "to": "Adaptable vaccine platforms", "id": "adaptable-vaccine-platforms", "moved": null }, { "from": "Advanced nuclear", "to": "Advanced nuclear fission", "id": "advanced-nuclear-fission", "moved": null }, { "from": "Pension & care system strain", "to": "Age-related fiscal liabilities", "id": "age-related-fiscal-liabilities", "moved": null }, { "from": "AI agents & knowledge-work automation", "to": "AI & knowledge-work automation", "id": "ai-and-knowledge-work-automation", "moved": null }, { "from": "AI-mediated information", "to": "AI-mediated information access", "id": "ai-mediated-information-access", "moved": null }, { "from": "Bank resilience & deposit flight", "to": "Bank funding & deposit mobility", "id": "bank-funding-and-deposit-mobility", "moved": null }, { "from": "Biodiversity & nature loss", "to": "Biodiversity & ecosystem loss", "id": "biodiversity-and-ecosystem-loss", "moved": null }, { "from": "Precision medicine & oncology", "to": "Biomarker-guided precision medicine", "id": "biomarker-guided-precision-medicine", "moved": null }, { "from": "Biometrics", "to": "Biometric identification", "id": "biometric-identification", "moved": null }, { "from": "Care economy & unpaid work", "to": "Care labour demand growth", "id": "care-labour-demand-growth", "moved": null }, { "from": "Chronic disease burden", "to": "Chronic disease & obesity burden", "id": "chronic-disease-and-obesity-burden", "moved": null }, { "from": "Civil unrest", "to": "Civil unrest & protest mobilisation", "id": "civil-unrest-and-protest-mobilisation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Climate migration", "to": "Climate-related population relocation", "id": "climate-related-population-relocation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Space economy", "to": "Commercial launch & space access", "id": "commercial-launch-and-space-access", "moved": null }, { "from": "Commercial real estate stress", "to": "Commercial property repricing", "id": "commercial-property-repricing", "moved": null }, { "from": "Commodity price volatility", "to": "Commodity dependence & price volatility", "id": "commodity-dependence-and-price-volatility", "moved": null }, { "from": "Aid retrenchment", "to": "Concessional finance scarcity", "id": "concessional-finance-scarcity", "moved": null }, { "from": "Internet of Things", "to": "Connected infrastructure operation", "id": "connected-infrastructure-operation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Maritime chokepoint dependence", "to": "Contested maritime access", "id": "contested-maritime-access", "moved": null }, { "from": "Corruption & kleptocracy", "to": "Corruption & state capture", "id": "corruption-and-state-capture", "moved": null }, { "from": "Supply-chain concentration", "to": "Critical input supplier concentration", "id": "critical-input-supplier-concentration", "moved": null }, { "from": "Critical minerals supply", "to": "Critical minerals supply constraints", "id": "critical-minerals-supply-constraints", "moved": null }, { "from": "Data-centre power demand", "to": "Data-centre power & water demand", "id": "data-centre-power-and-water-demand", "moved": null }, { "from": "Transnational repression & diaspora politics", "to": "Diaspora politics & transnational repression", "id": "diaspora-politics-and-transnational-repression", "moved": null }, { "from": "Digital & remote care", "to": "Digital & AI-supported care", "id": "digital-and-ai-supported-care", "moved": null }, { "from": "Digital & services trade", "to": "Digital & services trade growth", "id": "digital-and-services-trade-growth", "moved": null }, { "from": "Cash decline & payment dependence", "to": "Digital payments & cash decline", "id": "digital-payments-and-cash-decline", "moved": null }, { "from": "Dollar dependence & payment-rail fragmentation", "to": "Dollar dependence & payment fragmentation", "id": "dollar-dependence-and-payment-fragmentation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Early-warning systems", "to": "Early-warning coverage", "id": "early-warning-coverage", "moved": null }, { "from": "Geospatial technology", "to": "Earth observation & geospatial sensing", "id": "earth-observation-and-geospatial-sensing", "moved": null }, { "from": "Electric transport", "to": "Electric transport & charging networks", "id": "electric-transport-and-charging-networks", "moved": null }, { "from": "Electrification of heat, transport & industry", "to": "Electrification of heat & industry", "id": "electrification-of-heat-and-industry", "moved": null }, { "from": "Emerging middle class", "to": "Emerging middle-class demand", "id": "emerging-middle-class-demand", "moved": null }, { "from": "Inequality", "to": "Entrenched opportunity inequality", "id": "entrenched-opportunity-inequality", "moved": null }, { "from": "Export controls & economic statecraft", "to": "Export controls & economic coercion", "id": "export-controls-and-economic-coercion", "moved": null }, { "from": "Fertiliser dependence", "to": "Fertiliser supply dependence", "id": "fertiliser-supply-dependence", "moved": null }, { "from": "Loss of firm & black-start capacity", "to": "Firm & black-start capacity", "id": "firm-and-black-start-capacity", "moved": null }, { "from": "Food waste", "to": "Food loss & waste", "id": "food-loss-and-waste", "moved": null }, { "from": "Foreign direct investment slowdown", "to": "Foreign investment slowdown & selectivity", "id": "foreign-investment-slowdown-and-selectivity", "moved": null }, { "from": "Fuel logistics & refining capacity", "to": "Fossil fuel supply & refining", "id": "fossil-fuel-supply-and-refining", "moved": null }, { "from": "Learning loss & education quality", "to": "Foundational learning deficits", "id": "foundational-learning-deficits", "moved": null }, { "from": "Water stress & transboundary water", "to": "Freshwater stress & transboundary water", "id": "freshwater-stress-and-transboundary-water", "moved": null }, { "from": "Gender equality & inclusion", "to": "Gender participation divergence", "id": "gender-participation-divergence", "moved": null }, { "from": "Humanoid robotics", "to": "General-purpose & humanoid robotics", "id": "general-purpose-and-humanoid-robotics", "moved": null }, { "from": "Artificial intelligence", "to": "General-purpose AI capability", "id": "general-purpose-ai-capability", "moved": null }, { "from": "Graduate labour market squeeze", "to": "Graduate skill mismatch", "id": "graduate-skill-mismatch", "moved": null }, { "from": "Demand flexibility & smart metering", "to": "Grid expansion & demand flexibility", "id": "grid-expansion-and-demand-flexibility", "moved": null }, { "from": "Healthcare system reform", "to": "Health system demand imbalance", "id": "health-system-demand-imbalance", "moved": null }, { "from": "Health workforce shortage", "to": "Health workforce scarcity", "id": "health-workforce-scarcity", "moved": null }, { "from": "Pollution & contaminants", "to": "Heat & pollution health burden", "id": "heat-and-pollution-health-burden", "moved": null }, { "from": "Hybrid & grey-zone warfare", "to": "Hybrid & grey-zone coercion", "id": "hybrid-and-grey-zone-coercion", "moved": null }, { "from": "Peak oil demand & petrostate exposure", "to": "Hydrocarbon revenue dependence", "id": "hydrocarbon-revenue-dependence", "moved": null }, { "from": "Robotics & automation", "to": "Industrial robotics & automation", "id": "industrial-robotics-and-automation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Informal employment", "to": "Informal employment persistence", "id": "informal-employment-persistence", "moved": null }, { "from": "Infrastructure ageing", "to": "Infrastructure ageing & maintenance backlog", "id": "infrastructure-ageing-and-maintenance-backlog", "moved": null }, { "from": "Climate finance & loss and damage", "to": "International climate finance gaps", "id": "international-climate-finance-gaps", "moved": null }, { "from": "Just-in-time logistics & thin inventories", "to": "Lean inventories & just-in-time logistics", "id": "lean-inventories-and-just-in-time-logistics", "moved": null }, { "from": "Reskilling & education technology", "to": "Lifelong learning & digital reskilling", "id": "lifelong-learning-and-digital-reskilling", "moved": null }, { "from": "Missile & long-range strike proliferation", "to": "Long-range strike proliferation", "id": "long-range-strike-proliferation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Mental health", "to": "Mental health demand growth", "id": "mental-health-demand-growth", "moved": null }, { "from": "Rise of middle powers", "to": "Middle-power diplomatic leverage", "id": "middle-power-diplomatic-leverage", "moved": null }, { "from": "Nuclear & WMD proliferation", "to": "Nuclear arsenal growth & proliferation", "id": "nuclear-arsenal-growth-and-proliferation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Zoonotic spillover & pandemic risk", "to": "Pathogen emergence pressure", "id": "pathogen-emergence-pressure", "moved": null }, { "from": "Armed conflict at post-war highs", "to": "Persistent armed conflict", "id": "persistent-armed-conflict", "moved": null }, { "from": "Malnutrition", "to": "Persistent nutritional deprivation", "id": "persistent-nutritional-deprivation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Falling fertility & population decline", "to": "Persistently low fertility", "id": "persistently-low-fertility", "moved": null }, { "from": "Pharmaceutical supply concentration", "to": "Pharmaceutical input concentration", "id": "pharmaceutical-input-concentration", "moved": null }, { "from": "Ageing population", "to": "Population ageing", "id": "population-ageing", "moved": null }, { "from": "Port & shipping concentration", "to": "Port & carrier concentration", "id": "port-and-carrier-concentration", "moved": "Strategic Infrastructure to Trade & Investment" }, { "from": "Public procurement reform", "to": "Public procurement capability", "id": "public-procurement-capability", "moved": null }, { "from": "Rail & mass transit investment", "to": "Rail & mass transit expansion", "id": "rail-and-mass-transit-expansion", "moved": null }, { "from": "Ransomware & cybercrime", "to": "Ransomware & cyber extortion", "id": "ransomware-and-cyber-extortion", "moved": null }, { "from": "Regional trade agreements", "to": "Regional trade agreement deepening", "id": "regional-trade-agreement-deepening", "moved": null }, { "from": "Energy poverty", "to": "Reliable energy access gaps", "id": "reliable-energy-access-gaps", "moved": null }, { "from": "Renewable energy", "to": "Renewable generation expansion", "id": "renewable-generation-expansion", "moved": null }, { "from": "Child & maternal health", "to": "Reproductive, maternal & child health", "id": "reproductive-maternal-and-child-health", "moved": null }, { "from": "Building codes & resilient construction", "to": "Resilient construction & asset adaptation", "id": "resilient-construction-and-asset-adaptation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Sanctions evasion & shadow fleets", "to": "Sanctions circumvention networks", "id": "sanctions-circumvention-networks", "moved": null }, { "from": "Hygiene & sanitation", "to": "Sanitation & hygiene access gaps", "id": "sanitation-and-hygiene-access-gaps", "moved": null }, { "from": "Satellite mega-constellations", "to": "Satellite connectivity expansion", "id": "satellite-connectivity-expansion", "moved": "Critical Technology to Strategic Infrastructure" }, { "from": "GNSS & timing dependence", "to": "Satellite positioning & timing dependence", "id": "satellite-positioning-and-timing-dependence", "moved": null }, { "from": "Shifting economic power", "to": "Shifting economic weight", "id": "shifting-economic-weight", "moved": null }, { "from": "Brain drain & talent migration", "to": "Skilled & research talent migration", "id": "skilled-and-research-talent-migration", "moved": null }, { "from": "Economic stagnation", "to": "Slow growth & fiscal space", "id": "slow-growth-and-fiscal-space", "moved": null }, { "from": "Weak social protection", "to": "Social protection coverage gaps", "id": "social-protection-coverage-gaps", "moved": null }, { "from": "Solar & storage cost collapse", "to": "Solar manufacturing cost decline", "id": "solar-manufacturing-cost-decline", "moved": null }, { "from": "Creditor fragmentation", "to": "Sovereign creditor fragmentation", "id": "sovereign-creditor-fragmentation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Sovereign debt accumulation", "to": "Sovereign debt & interest burden", "id": "sovereign-debt-and-interest-burden", "moved": null }, { "from": "Breadbasket & food export concentration", "to": "Staple food export concentration", "id": "staple-food-export-concentration", "moved": null }, { "from": "Asset bubbles & stretched valuations", "to": "Stretched asset valuations", "id": "stretched-asset-valuations", "moved": null }, { "from": "Inflation & cost of living", "to": "Structural inflation pressure", "id": "structural-inflation-pressure", "moved": null }, { "from": "Subsea cable & pipeline vulnerability", "to": "Subsea cable & pipeline dependence", "id": "subsea-cable-and-pipeline-dependence", "moved": null }, { "from": "Sustainable consumption", "to": "Sustainable consumption & product durability", "id": "sustainable-consumption-and-product-durability", "moved": null }, { "from": "Sustainable finance", "to": "Sustainable finance & environmental risk", "id": "sustainable-finance-and-environmental-risk", "moved": null }, { "from": "Tariff escalation", "to": "Tariff barrier normalisation", "id": "tariff-barrier-normalisation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Tax base erosion & global tax reform", "to": "Tax base erosion & coordination", "id": "tax-base-erosion-and-coordination", "moved": null }, { "from": "Talent & labour shortages", "to": "Technical & occupational skill shortages", "id": "technical-and-occupational-skill-shortages", "moved": null }, { "from": "Crypto-assets & tokenisation", "to": "Tokenisation of financial assets", "id": "tokenisation-of-financial-assets", "moved": null }, { "from": "Deglobalisation", "to": "Trade & investment fragmentation", "id": "trade-and-investment-fragmentation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Trade, shipping & logistics digitalisation", "to": "Trade & logistics digitalisation", "id": "trade-and-logistics-digitalisation", "moved": null }, { "from": "Infrastructure corridor competition", "to": "Trade corridor competition", "id": "trade-corridor-competition", "moved": null }, { "from": "Urbanisation", "to": "Urban population concentration", "id": "urban-population-concentration", "moved": null }, { "from": "Water technology & desalination", "to": "Water treatment & desalination", "id": "water-treatment-and-desalination", "moved": null }, { "from": "Youth unemployment & lack of opportunity", "to": "Youth employment exclusion", "id": "youth-employment-exclusion", "moved": null }, { "from": "Demographic pressure in young nations", "to": "Youth population expansion", "id": "youth-population-expansion", "moved": null } ], "moved": [ { "name": "Critical infrastructure protection", "id": "critical-infrastructure-protection", "from": "strategic-infrastructure", "to": "national-security" }, { "name": "Port & carrier concentration", "id": "port-and-carrier-concentration", "from": "strategic-infrastructure", "to": "trade-investment" }, { "name": "Satellite connectivity expansion", "id": "satellite-connectivity-expansion", "from": "critical-technology", "to": "strategic-infrastructure" } ], "merged": [ { "from": "Obesity & GLP-1 medicines", "from_domain": "human-capital", "into": "Chronic disease & obesity burden", "id": "chronic-disease-and-obesity-burden" }, { "from": "Earth system tipping points", "from_domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "into": "Climate change & physical risk", "id": "climate-change-and-physical-risk" }, { "from": "Smart cities & buildings", "from_domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "into": "Connected infrastructure operation", "id": "connected-infrastructure-operation" }, { "from": "Indo-Pacific maritime disputes", "from_domain": "national-security", "into": "Contested maritime access", "id": "contested-maritime-access" }, { "from": "AI diagnostics & predictive health", "from_domain": "human-capital", "into": "Digital & AI-supported care", "id": "digital-and-ai-supported-care" }, { "from": "Digital payments & FinTech", "from_domain": "financial-strength", "into": "Digital payments & cash decline", "id": "digital-payments-and-cash-decline" }, { "from": "Fossil fuel resurgence", "from_domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "into": "Fossil fuel supply & refining", "id": "fossil-fuel-supply-and-refining" }, { "from": "Grid enhancement", "from_domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "into": "Grid expansion & demand flexibility", "id": "grid-expansion-and-demand-flexibility" }, { "from": "Heat stress & labour productivity", "from_domain": "human-capital", "into": "Heat & pollution health burden", "id": "heat-and-pollution-health-burden" }, { "from": "Cyber insecurity", "from_domain": "national-security", "into": "Ransomware & cyber extortion", "id": "ransomware-and-cyber-extortion" }, { "from": "Friend-shoring & regional trade blocs", "from_domain": "trade-investment", "into": "Regional trade agreement deepening", "id": "regional-trade-agreement-deepening" }, { "from": "Women's health & fertility care", "from_domain": "human-capital", "into": "Reproductive, maternal & child health", "id": "reproductive-maternal-and-child-health" }, { "from": "Seismic & geophysical hazard", "from_domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "into": "Resilient construction & asset adaptation", "id": "resilient-construction-and-asset-adaptation" }, { "from": "Climate adaptation & resilience", "from_domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "into": "Resilient construction & asset adaptation", "id": "resilient-construction-and-asset-adaptation" }, { "from": "Space weather exposure", "from_domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "into": "Satellite positioning & timing dependence", "id": "satellite-positioning-and-timing-dependence" } ], "dropped": [ { "name": "Defence technology", "domain": "national-security" }, { "name": "Changing nature of work", "domain": "human-capital" }, { "name": "US policy volatility", "domain": "information-influence" }, { "name": "China's economic slowdown", "domain": "financial-strength" }, { "name": "Taiwan Strait tension", "domain": "national-security" }, { "name": "Russia–NATO confrontation", "domain": "national-security" }, { "name": "Middle East instability", "domain": "national-security" }, { "name": "Extended reality & immersive media", "domain": "production-innovation" }, { "name": "Longevity science", "domain": "human-capital" } ], "added": [ { "name": "AI inference efficiency", "id": "ai-inference-efficiency", "domain": "critical-technology", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Quantum sensing & timing", "id": "quantum-sensing-and-timing", "domain": "critical-technology", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Orbital debris & congestion", "id": "orbital-debris-and-congestion", "domain": "critical-technology", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Urban cooling infrastructure", "id": "urban-cooling-infrastructure", "domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Agricultural soil degradation", "id": "agricultural-soil-degradation", "domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Food storage & cold chains", "id": "food-storage-and-cold-chains", "domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "support": 1, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Military logistics complexity", "id": "military-logistics-complexity", "domain": "national-security", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "AI-supported military decisions", "id": "ai-supported-military-decisions", "domain": "national-security", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Electromagnetic spectrum contest", "id": "electromagnetic-spectrum-contest", "domain": "national-security", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "State cyber intrusion & prepositioning", "id": "state-cyber-intrusion-and-prepositioning", "domain": "national-security", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Undersea military competition", "id": "undersea-military-competition", "domain": "national-security", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Migrant integration demands", "id": "migrant-integration-demands", "domain": "human-capital", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Healthy lifespan divergence", "id": "healthy-lifespan-divergence", "domain": "human-capital", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Media provenance & authentication", "id": "media-provenance-and-authentication", "domain": "information-influence", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Digital language representation gaps", "id": "digital-language-representation-gaps", "domain": "information-influence", "support": 1, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Credibility of external commitments", "id": "credibility-of-external-commitments", "domain": "information-influence", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Algorithmic accountability & bias", "id": "algorithmic-accountability-and-bias", "domain": "governance-integrity", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "External liquidity buffer requirements", "id": "external-liquidity-buffer-requirements", "domain": "financial-strength", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Domestic capital market deepening", "id": "domestic-capital-market-deepening", "domain": "financial-strength", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Financial market infrastructure resilience", "id": "financial-market-infrastructure-resilience", "domain": "financial-strength", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Technology diffusion & productivity gaps", "id": "technology-diffusion-and-productivity-gaps", "domain": "production-innovation", "support": 3, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Aquaculture intensification", "id": "aquaculture-intensification", "domain": "production-innovation", "support": 1, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Non-tariff compliance & traceability", "id": "non-tariff-compliance-and-traceability", "domain": "trade-investment", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] }, { "name": "Intellectual property access dependence", "id": "intellectual-property-access-dependence", "domain": "trade-investment", "support": 2, "takes_in": [] } ] }, "reconciliation": { "note": "Changes made across domains after the nine domain cuts, so that no force appears twice and none falls between two domains.", "changes": [ { "action": "dropped", "domain": "governance-integrity", "name": "Digital jurisdiction fragmentation", "reason": "The same force as Digital sovereignty & data localisation, kept in critical technology; its legal side was written into that description." }, { "action": "added", "domain": "strategic-infrastructure", "name": "Satellite connectivity expansion", "reason": "Each of the two domain cuts left it to the other. All three models hold it." } ] } }, "scores": { "pairs": 5000, "members": [ { "key": "A", "model": "DeepSeek V4 Pro" }, { "key": "B", "model": "Mistral Large" }, { "key": "C", "model": "GPT-6.1" } ], "method": "Each member scored every trend against every scenario on the seven-point rubric. The score kept is the median of the three.", "distribution": [ { "level": 0, "share": 73.9 }, { "level": 1, "share": 8 }, { "level": 2, "share": 7.8 }, { "level": 3, "share": 5 }, { "level": 4, "share": 3 }, { "level": 5, "share": 1.7 }, { "level": 6, "share": 0.7 } ], "spread": [ { "range": 0, "share": 59 }, { "range": 1, "share": 15 }, { "range": 2, "share": 12 }, { "range": 3, "share": 9.3 }, { "range": 4, "share": 3.6 }, { "range": 5, "share": 1 }, { "range": 6, "share": 0 } ], "agreement_within_one": { "A-B": 89.4, "A-C": 83.1, "B-C": 79.1 }, "wide_disagreements": 231, "widest": [ { "trend": "general-purpose-ai-capability", "scenario": "S20", "scores": [ 0, 4, 0 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "frontier-model-concentration", "scenario": "S01", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "frontier-model-concentration", "scenario": "S13", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "automated-ai-research", "scenario": "S08", "scores": [ 3, 0, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "ai-accelerated-science", "scenario": "S16", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "ai-accelerated-science", "scenario": "S20", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "ai-inference-efficiency", "scenario": "S17", "scores": [ 0, 2, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "compute-scaling-and-ai-infrastructure", "scenario": "S01", "scores": [ 1, 0, 4 ], "kept": 1 }, { "trend": "compute-scaling-and-ai-infrastructure", "scenario": "S02", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "compute-scaling-and-ai-infrastructure", "scenario": "S13", "scores": [ 1, 0, 4 ], "kept": 1 }, { "trend": "compute-scaling-and-ai-infrastructure", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 2, 0, 5 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "cloud-and-edge-computing", "scenario": "S01", "scores": [ 1, 0, 4 ], "kept": 1 }, { "trend": "cloud-and-edge-computing", "scenario": "S04", "scores": [ 1, 2, 5 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "cloud-and-edge-computing", "scenario": "S09", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "cloud-and-edge-computing", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "digital-sovereignty-and-data-localisation", "scenario": "S01", "scores": [ 1, 2, 5 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "digital-sovereignty-and-data-localisation", "scenario": "S12", "scores": [ 2, 0, 5 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "digital-sovereignty-and-data-localisation", "scenario": "S13", "scores": [ 0, 1, 5 ], "kept": 1 }, { "trend": "biometric-identification", "scenario": "S09", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "earth-observation-and-geospatial-sensing", "scenario": "S14", "scores": [ 0, 4, 4 ], "kept": 4 }, { "trend": "earth-observation-and-geospatial-sensing", "scenario": "S16", "scores": [ 0, 3, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "commercial-launch-and-space-access", "scenario": "S14", "scores": [ 0, 5, 0 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "general-purpose-and-humanoid-robotics", "scenario": "S17", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "advanced-materials", "scenario": "S01", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "advanced-materials", "scenario": "S17", "scores": [ 1, 2, 5 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "synthetic-biology-and-biomanufacturing", "scenario": "S16", "scores": [ 1, 0, 4 ], "kept": 1 }, { "trend": "synthetic-biology-and-biomanufacturing", "scenario": "S17", "scores": [ 1, 4, 5 ], "kept": 4 }, { "trend": "gene-editing-and-cell-therapies", "scenario": "S19", "scores": [ 0, 4, 0 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "data-centre-power-and-water-demand", "scenario": "S04", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "distributed-power", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "electric-transport-and-charging-networks", "scenario": "S04", "scores": [ 1, 0, 4 ], "kept": 1 }, { "trend": "electrification-of-heat-and-industry", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 3, 0, 5 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "grid-expansion-and-demand-flexibility", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 5, 0, 6 ], "kept": 5 }, { "trend": "renewable-generation-expansion", "scenario": "S03", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "firm-and-black-start-capacity", "scenario": "S03", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "firm-and-black-start-capacity", "scenario": "S07", "scores": [ 3, 0, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "firm-and-black-start-capacity", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 4, 0, 5 ], "kept": 4 }, { "trend": "fossil-fuel-supply-and-refining", "scenario": "S04", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "fossil-fuel-supply-and-refining", "scenario": "S14", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "fossil-fuel-supply-and-refining", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 2, 0, 5 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "reliable-energy-access-gaps", "scenario": "S04", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "reliable-energy-access-gaps", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 2, 0, 5 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "strategic-stockpiles-and-reserves", "scenario": "S01", "scores": [ 4, 0, 5 ], "kept": 4 }, { "trend": "strategic-stockpiles-and-reserves", "scenario": "S04", "scores": [ 3, 0, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "strategic-stockpiles-and-reserves", "scenario": "S10", "scores": [ 3, 0, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "infrastructure-ageing-and-maintenance-backlog", "scenario": "S11", "scores": [ 0, 0, 4 ], "kept": 0 }, { "trend": "infrastructure-ageing-and-maintenance-backlog", "scenario": "S15", "scores": [ 1, 0, 4 ], "kept": 1 }, { "trend": "climate-change-and-physical-risk", "scenario": "S07", "scores": [ 5, 0, 5 ], "kept": 5 }, { "trend": "climate-change-and-physical-risk", "scenario": "S16", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "urban-population-concentration", "scenario": "S04", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "urban-population-concentration", "scenario": "S10", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "water-treatment-and-desalination", "scenario": "S04", "scores": [ 3, 0, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "water-treatment-and-desalination", "scenario": "S07", "scores": [ 3, 0, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "dams-reservoirs-and-flood-defence", "scenario": "S07", "scores": [ 5, 0, 5 ], "kept": 5 }, { "trend": "biodiversity-and-ecosystem-loss", "scenario": "S07", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "food-storage-and-cold-chains", "scenario": "S20", "scores": [ 3, 0, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "next-generation-mobile-networks", "scenario": "S01", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 }, { "trend": "connected-infrastructure-operation", "scenario": "S09", "scores": [ 3, 0, 4 ], "kept": 3 }, { "trend": "satellite-connectivity-expansion", "scenario": "S07", "scores": [ 4, 0, 4 ], "kept": 4 }, { "trend": "great-power-competition", "scenario": "S14", "scores": [ 2, 0, 4 ], "kept": 2 } ] } }